Abstract
Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan have set quantitative targets for tourism’s contribution to the economy in their policy documents, yet these targets rest on non-comparable indicators. The article assesses how the choice of an indicator of tourism’s contribution to GDP affects the content of sector targets and the ability to monitor sustainable tourism, including under target 8.9 of the Sustainable Development Goals. The study combines a comparative analysis of the Tourism Satellite Account (TSA) and World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC) approaches, official statistics of Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan for 2019–2025, a review of policy documents and calculations of the required outpacing growth rates. In 2024, Uzbekistan’s tourism direct GDP accounted for 2.5% of GDP, while the baseline in Presidential Resolution PP-348 is 3.5% and the WTTC estimate for 2025 is 6%; in Kazakhstan, the share of value added generated directly by tourism was about 1% and that of the tourism industries about 3%. Depending on the indicator chosen, the target of “7% of GDP by 2030” requires tourism to outgrow the economy by 3.1 to 18.7% per year. A three-level system of target-management indicators consistent with international statistical standards is proposed.